Research note
May 2026 polarity audit
19 of 36 indicators had their Direction declared opposite to what the data said — the biggest research finding of the project, lens by lens.
2 min read
The biggest research finding of the project so far. Per-indicator IC analysis on 10 years of cached data showed 19 of 36 actionable indicators had their Direction declared opposite to what the data said. Specifically:
- Credit lens (8 of 8 inverted, all flipped). Tight spreads / strong credit ETFs / strong KRE-KBE all preceded LOWER forward returns, not higher. This is the late-cycle / crowded-credit pattern: tight spreads mark complacency, not opportunity. The framework's "tight = risk-on" framing was empirically wrong over 10y.
- Volatility lens (4 of 7 inverted, all flipped). Low VIX / contango term structure / low VVIX are crowded-short-vol complacency that mean-reverts. High VIX (panic) marks the actionable bottom. Skew and MOVE were noise (dropped to weight 0).
- Breadth lens (3 of 6 inverted, all flipped). Stretched breadth (high % above MA, small-cap leadership) is crowded longs that mean-revert. Depressed breadth marks the entry.
- Cross-asset lens (4 of 5 inverted, all flipped). Stretched copper/gold, AUD/JPY, oil, and gold-vs-real-yield richness are late-cycle euphoria signals; safety-bid moves coincide with bottoms.
- Sentiment lens (6 of 6 correctly oriented). The only lens that worked as built. AAII, NAAIM, SPY-200dma deviation, VIX complacency, global breadth, HYG appetite all score
OK / keep. - Macro lens (mostly noise). Net liquidity, NFCI, real yields, breakevens — most scored below the noise threshold. Yield curve 2s10s and DXY were the survivors.
The full per-indicator table with current IC / polarity / weight is at /validation (scroll to "Per-indicator IC"). Weight changes are documented in docs/INDICATORS.md with 0.0 ⚠ markers for zero-weighted indicators.
This article is also a chapter of the Education page.