Research note

Tactical vs strategic composite

Two composite scores from the same lenses: one tilted to the 20-day horizon, one to 60 days — and why their disagreement is itself the signal.

2 min read

The dashboard reports two composite scores, both built from the same lens scores but with different weights:

  • Tactical (20d-tilted) — original weights tuned for monthly entry/exit timing. Sentiment, volatility, breadth dominate (these are the lenses with the strongest 20d-horizon IC).
  • Strategic (60d-tilted) — weights proportional to per-lens IC at 60d, the quarterly horizon. Macro, credit, cross-asset dominate (these are the lenses that operate at economic-cycle timeframes).

Why two scores

The validation work showed that lenses don't all predict at the same horizon. Sentiment and volatility predict the next month well; macro and credit predict the next quarter much better than the next month. A single composite has to pick a horizon, and either one under-uses the other lenses.

Per-lens IC at each horizon (10y prod data, post-polarity audit):

LensIC 5dIC 20dIC 60d20d wt60d wt
credit+0.096+0.216+0.32920%27%
macro+0.067+0.083+0.30320%25%
crossasset+0.116+0.113+0.22210%18%
volatility+0.121+0.179+0.16020%13%
breadth+0.089+0.155+0.11615%9%
sentiment+0.076+0.129+0.09315%8%

When they disagree

The disagreement is the signal. If tactical is +30 (Bull) and strategic is −10 (Neutral), the short-term picture is bullish but the quarterly drivers (macro, credit) are softer — late-cycle momentum chase. Reverse case (tactical Neutral, strategic Bull): the macro setup is supportive but sentiment / vol haven't confirmed yet — the constructive case for adding risk is building, not yet active.

The overview gauge (/) draws both needles on the same dial — 20d as the solid needle, 60d as the dashed one. If they're ≥20 points apart, a small footnote calls out the direction of disagreement.


This article is also a chapter of the Education page.

Not financial advice

Built for education. Backtests are historical; they do not predict future returns and are not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.

connecting…